(Image source:
https://www.google.com/search?sca_esv=d49d498028d0eec8&rlz=1C1CHBD_enMY917MY917&sxsrf=AE3TifM1-mgh2fQ8rJ-BDXOd2HoW33ErhQ:1750409371843&q=coaching&udm=2&fbs=AIIjpHxU7SXXniUZfeShr2fp4giZ1Y6MJ25_tmWITc7uy4KIeiAkWG4OlBE2zyCTMjPbGmPgfe_7ak8LUsonpWCvT6w6csnyTymMQ2XHqFKxVhyiTsB7_xjE7pCrlhvgmABFb-qvUXFeXLKmP5HUMuOwzi3W7YDpORc67v9mLSkQHRt4AKqGi9dyO-keM7IQ79ZYnZFqT5u-Q65xNOQ8PY-9XmwIuX2eAQ&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjP28eGz_-NAxV4lFYBHaTuJtkQtKgLegQIERAB&biw=1536&bih=703&dpr=1.25#vhid=zNDxLsNpHMnjXM&vssid=mosaic)
Coaching-Based Feedback vs. Command Feedback: Which Builds a Better Workforce?
Feedback is the lifeblood of team performance—but not all feedback is created equal.
In many organisations, especially within SMEs or traditional management settings, feedback is still delivered in a command-and-control style: direct, top-down, and focused on what went wrong.
But today’s talent—especially Millennials and Gen Z—expect a more supportive, developmental approach. They don’t just want to be told what to fix; they want guidance on how to improve, grow, and feel heard.
This is where coaching-based feedback comes in. It transforms the way managers communicate with their teams—from controlling to empowering, from criticism to collaboration.
In this article, we’ll break down the difference between command feedback and coaching-based feedback, why it matters in today’s workplace, and how your organisation can start making the shift.
Command feedback is a traditional form of performance communication where:
Feedback is one-directional, from manager to employee
The goal is often compliance or correction, not development
Conversations are brief, task-focused, and sometimes confrontational
It uses phrases like:
“You didn’t meet the target.”
“Just do what I told you.”
“That’s not how it should be done.”
While sometimes necessary in urgent or high-risk situations, overusing command-style feedback leads to:
Coaching-based feedback is a more modern, collaborative style of communication where:
Managers act like mentors, not just supervisors
The focus is on improvement, learning, and potential
Employees are invited into the conversation, not just given orders
It uses guiding questions like:
“What do you think worked well?”
“What would you try differently next time?”
“How can I support you better in this?”
This approach transforms feedback from a moment of judgment into a growth opportunity—and employees appreciate that.
Today’s employees—especially in SMEs and tech-driven industries—don’t just want to be managed; they want to be coached and empowered.
Here’s why coaching-style feedback is more effective in modern teams:
Let’s turn some common feedback moments into coaching-based conversations:
These subtle shifts build ownership, confidence, and loyalty—especially for younger or high-potential employees.
(Image source:
You don’t need formal coaching certifications or large HR budgets to apply this style of feedback. Here’s how smaller teams or team leaders can start:
✅ Train Managers in Active Listening
Coaching starts by listening more than talking. Let employees speak before jumping to corrections.
✅ Use Open-Ended Questions in 1:1s
Encourage self-reflection with prompts like:
“What went well this week?”
“What would you like to do differently next time?”
✅ Focus on Strengths, Not Just Gaps
Recognise what’s working well. This boosts morale and opens the door to constructive discussions.
✅ Make Feedback Regular, Not Annual
Avoid only giving feedback during appraisals. Weekly or monthly check-ins drive consistency.
✅ Lead by Example
If managers show vulnerability, ask for feedback themselves, and model openness—teams will follow.
At MOCHI Technologies, we believe that feedback should not be feared—it should be fuel for growth.
By shifting from command-style corrections to coaching-style conversations, organisations of all sizes—especially SMEs—can build stronger trust, better engagement, and a culture of shared ownership. It doesn’t take more money. It takes a mindset shift in leadership.
If your teams feel safe to learn, fail, and grow—they’ll stay, and they’ll thrive.